Investing in the new economy
 he who hesitates...
   
     
   
           
           
           
 
Chris Williams is a partner in Global Corporate Finance and heads the Technology and eBusiness team. He advises both large and smaller corporates, specialising in strategy, fundraising, acquisitions and divestitures.

For more information on eBusiness funding - including investments spinouts and acquisitions, contact Chris on or via e-mail: christopher.j.williams.
Investing in the new economy
he who hesitates...

Bricks & mortar companies are now active in new economy investment. The opportunities for acquisitions and eBusiness investment abound - but don't hesitate too long. Being prepared and moving fast are your best assets...


Opportunities for dot coms

Opportunities for major corporates

Invest directly in new economy businesses

Acquire new economy businesses

Spin off new economy businesses


The best of both worlds




         
 

Have major corporates missed the new economy investment boat?
Absolutely not.



 

Major corporates versus start-ups
Activity in eBusiness has typically been pitched as a battle between 'old economy' corporates and 'new economy' start-ups. So who's winning? Can they both win? Large corporates have often seemed sluggish compared to the nimble young businesses that first grasped new economy opportunities. But now they are fighting back.

Compared to the dot.com new kids on the block, major corporates have several strategic advantages. Andersen's survey of more than one hundred UK senior executives highlighted a few of those advantages.

  • Brand: "Off-line companies already have developed brands. Internet start-ups don't."
  • Established market positions: "(Traditional companies)... have the ability to deliver. And they have the experience in this market."
  • Robust supply chains: "There is no infrastructure if you set up online from scratch. There would be problems that are simple to deal with for traditional businesses, eg returned products, that might be more complex for online companies."

But these strategic advantages do not mean that major corporates can afford to ignore the new economy. For quite a while, major corporates did lag in new economy investment. Now, however, many have established new economy strategies - and they have access to funds.

They are now in a position where they want to and are able to invest.


 
           
      Opportunities for dot.coms
Many dot.coms are experiencing a bout of funding sobriety. Venture capitalists (VCs) are still wary. The lessons from last Spring will not be forgotten in a hurry. The attitudes of VCs toward some early stage eBusinesses are significantly more risk averse. As a result, dot.coms may be in trouble. Typically their early funding was designed to cover only part of the loss-making phase. And VCs are not keen to cough up for the second round without a clearly defined path to profit.
  ^ Back to top
           
      Opportunities for major corporates
Have they missed the new economy investment boat? Absolutely not. In fact, we can expect to see traditional bricks & mortar corporates ramp up their new economy strategy in three ways.
  ^ Back to top
           
      1. Invest directly in new economy businesses
Technology companies proved this model in the 90s. Many industry leaders invested minority stakes in a broad range of companies that directly or indirectly offered the potential to increase demand for their own products. Intel is the quintessential example: it invested in a broad range of companies that individually offered the ability to increase demand for its chips. The result? As of 30 September 2000, Intel's capital portfolio in technology companies had a carrying value of over $2 billion. Cisco, Oracle and others have followed suit.

Similar opportunities exist for established corporates that are evaluating their eBusiness development options. Many large corporates are now considering direct investment to seed and learn from new economy businesses in their sector.

  ^ Back to top
           
      2. Acquire new economy businesses
This can be an attractive pairing: a new eBusiness looking to fuel its growth and a major corporate poised to convert it from a 'first mover' to a 'first to scale'. A recent example of this would be Great Universal Stores' (GUS') acquisition of jungle.com. Jungle provided GUS with a new economy expertise, brand, culture and capability that GUS could not have easily established itself. GUS, on the other hand, gave jungle.com the infrastructure (and operating cash) it needed to mature as an eBusiness.
  ^ Back to top
           
     

3. Spin off new economy businesses
In addition to major corporates investing in and buying new economy businesses, anticipate them spinning off new economy businesses as well. Why?

  • Large corporates have trading histories and financial results to defend. The deep initial losses and negative cash flows associated with developing a new economy business can be avoided or mitigated by spinning it off.
  • The spin-offs provide a culture and reward environment that is particularly attractive to hot talent (eg Dixons' spin off of freeserve, in which it still holds an 80 percent stake).
  • The independent new economy business provides a 'pure play', which investors can evaluate more effectively and, in some cases, assign a higher value. The end result is that the business gains access to cheaper fund
  ^ Back to top
           
  Dot.coms with a viable revenue model, in-house talent and a progressive culture bring a lot to the new economy table.  

The best of both worlds
An ideal marriage brings together major corporate backing with dot.com savoir faire. It goes without saying that dot.coms with a viable revenue model, in-house talent and a progressive culture bring a lot to the new economy table. Those which are well-versed in exploiting a wired economy - people skills, experience base, speed-to-market mentality - offer a great deal to major corporates who may only, as yet, aspire to having them.

Conversely, in their early stages, most dot.com businesses have inadequate cash flow... often none for the initial period. The reality is that dot.coms will struggle to gain support for additional funding from VCs in the next year. If VC support is not forthcoming, their likely alternatives will be to seek a corporate investor, sell or fold. Scaling back is not an option, as their revenue base is typically inadequate. Major corporate backers can provide more than cash... they can help online start-ups achieve the key criteria for success:

  • First-to-market. There has been a great deal of press on the advantages of a first mover strategy. The first entrant into a new market establishes itself quickly, becomes well known, and establishes a virtuous circle of a growing brand, customer base and revenue stream. This attracts cheaper funds and bigger scale investment. This, then, makes it even more attractive to customers, improves the brand, etc. In short, the first mover 'mops up' the whole market. Then momentum simply sustains and strengthens their lead.
  ^ Back to top
   
 

Major corporates: Options for new economy investment


Example

What they did...
         
Invest directly in
eBusinesses
  Reuters   Through the Reuters Greenhouse Fund, Reuters has invested in a variety of businesses that offer knowledge and business synergies or product relationships. These range from an early investment in Yahoo!... to more recent ones in companies such as Orchastream.

         
Acquire eBusinesses   GUS/ jungle.com   While valuations of dot.coms made many CEOs of traditional businesses green with envy, quite a few were ready to act when valuations changed. Great Universal Stores moved quickly to acquire jungle.com at a valuation of less than 10% of that anticipated before the aborted IPO. This market transaction has forged a powerful business: GUS provides logistical and operational expertise, while jungle.com offers an established online brand and technology.

         
Spin off eBusinesses   Dixons/ freeserve   By spinning off freeserve, Dixons was able to raise significant external capital and gain strong brand awareness for freeserve through its IPO. Moreover, this move isolated freeserve's early losses from the financials of Dixons' core business.

           
  When AviationX announced it was closing down, its CEO, Henrik Schroder, said his only regret was chasing "a flawed business strategy".  
  • First-to-scale. The first mover story has clearly been discredited as the sole criterion for success - it does not guarantee 'first to scale'. A bricks & mortar brand and an efficient supply chain may prove invaluable. It's not uncommon to see online businesses now acquiring off-line businesses. A good example of such a deal was eBookers' acquisition of Flight-bookers for $15 million in October 2000. Flight-bookers handles most of the online company's UK travel services. The deal eliminated the margin that eBookers paid to Flight-bookers and brought in its 200,000 plus customer list.

From bricks & mortars to 'bricks & clicks': be prepared To fund rapid growth, you need cash. You also need focus.

  • Clarify the likely impact of the new economy on your business. Assess the relevance of your existing revenue model and business processes in this new landscape.

  • Finalise your eBusiness strategy, allowing for future evolution of the new economy. It may not be possible to migrate your prior competitive advantage to future economic scenarios.

  • Know what type of online business is most compatible with your vision, culture and goals.

  • Evaluate your 'buy or build' options in terms of feasibility, cost and time.

  • If you decide to acquire a new economy business, get ready to act quickly. Once a dot.com looks to alternative funding sources, they won't be available for long. For example, after the failure of boo.com, Bright Station plc moved quickly to snap up boo.com's technology and web site development for £250,000. This appears to be a cheap acquisition, given the reputed £20 million that boo.com spent in developing this technology.

  • Approach new economy businesses to establish effective partnerships before they suffer funding pressure and their risk profile increases.

Get ready... get set...
Whether you invest, buy or build, if you are an established bricks & mortar company moving online, you will need to be proactive and move fast. Otherwise, you could be left watching your competitors seize the best opportunities.

  ^ Back to top
           
          ^ Back to top
           
    This document is available to download in its entirety, in an easy to read PDF (Portable Document File) format.

If your browser isn't already equiped with the plugin required to view this document, then you can download it, free of charge, from the Adobe website:


Adobe (for PDF files)

Investing in the new economy: he who hesitates...
file size: [84k]
   
      © 2000 Andersen. All rights reserved.    
           

Management Today Home Page Sitemap